Monday, July 22, 2019

Budget Deal Spends Even More!!!

From Laurie: MJ Today's Budget Deal is Fine

VOX Budget / Debt Ceiling

Fox News Real Compromise

I assume this means that financial responsibility is dead for now...

10 comments:

Sean said...

This is a bad deal for Democrats. If a Democrat wins the White House, Nancy Pelosi has handed that person a debt limit showdown in the opening months of their Presidency.

John said...

What would you have preferred?

I would have preferred they cut spending to match revenues, but that was unlikely. :-)

Laurie said...

to cut spending to match revenues for the discretionary part of the budget would require enormous cuts and is a really stupid idea. They should repeal Trump's tax cut.

Sean said...

My preference would be to go back to the pre-Gingrich days where Congress deemed the debt limit raised when a new budget was passed.

Laurie said...

https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2019/07/the-budge-deficit-is-all-about-taxes-not-spending/

John said...

Laurie's link

John said...

I always find it amusing how Kevin only shows the part of the story he likes.

See these graphs for more information

John said...

He is almost as bad as Trump...

He picked 1980 probably because it was Highest Federal Spend

And that was because it was during recessions where as we are in a GDP high point.

Sean said...

I don't see what the problem is. The graphs you link to show the exact same trend that Drum describes.

John said...

Sean,
It is game Kevin does with graphs.

By carefully starting at 1980 and ending at 2019 without noting when the USA was in recessions or expansions he misleads people into believing:

- that 1982 is like 2018, when it is really more like 2010
- that 1982 was "normal", when it is higher than the 1970s
- that we are on track to stay at 20% when the CBO says it will go higher soon

The long term number for revenues and spend is closer to 19%...